another simple edit.
I wouldn't recommend you to do this kind of edits Anelaidlives, mainly because, if i recall correctly, the only acceptable edits are those comming from japan itself or those meant for translation.
Since people try to respect the original work of the authors, regardless of our liking, both to prevent abuse edits on non abuse and non abuse edits on abuse.
Of course that's what i think it was like, i do recall some serious discussion about us not touching and editing the original work unless it were for translation. i think there was even a collage done as a protest and everything...
Since we have the rule that you can't post FF on abuse and abuse on FF in terms of comments, it seems safe that edits for either group will stay within that community providing no one decides to white-knight for either group.
But if the rule is no-edits, I will abide by it and just upload the better quality ones to danbooru.
i'm not sure if it's a rule i do recall it was a serious issue time ago, it started some serious discussion, from both sides and well, shit hit the fan and stuff, and i think it lead to us as the OYP, not to edit pics in that way, if they come edited from China and Japan so be it, but not us, since we clearly not favour our editing (specially because of how extreme both sides can be while editing works.)
Of course you're free to check if there is a rule or maybe ask if it's possible, i honestly don't know, yet i do recall an issue, and i think it would be better, for the sake of avoiding problems, first ask if it's allowed to upload edits like this and then upload them...
Isn't there a bottom half to this?
The final say on editing is you don't misrepresent the author's works. If there's abuse in it, keep it in. If its family friendly, don't add a flaming fist to kill the yukkuri.
Well this one was part of thispost #22219and also used herepost #18032
Basically the story of the anon that kidnaps a family make his alice rape them, then the only remaining one is the reimu and she denies the babies only to get worse treatment and the babies being pampered by the anon just to spite on her.
Of course i'm not sure if this counts, since it's a crop out, its still an edit in a way, that's why i think it would be better to analyze it and see if it's acceptable or not. After all we many times don't consider a "Family Friendly" looking pic one because it's a single page of an abuse comic.
Whether it is allowed or not, I like the idea of cropping this pic out because I liked the pic itself. I thank anelaidlives for sparing me the 5 minutes of work doing it myself and will download it now.
Tea has been uploading abuse edits post #21021 so I do not see why we can not have family friendly edits.
didn't know that. I'm generally towards the persuasion that edits are only to be done for translations and not images themselves, even if the artist is known for abuse. If the edits are funny or humor intended then it's fine. (warekara's)
Either way up to you guys. We can have both or none.
Maybe we could split the edit-tag to reflect if this pic was originally FF but became abuse (or vice versa). This way you can block the pictures out if you really hate them.
post #21021 is from 2ch; 2ch edits don't have to pass that test... It's just our edits. Which personally I find to be rather... odd; I don't see why our edits should be any worse than theirs.
As I've always said, edits made by this own community are generally frowned upon. You also need to keep in mind the original material. Like in the same way many violent series have non_violent frames, consideration needs to be given to the source.
I think its just the lack of communication between original artists and the editors. At least on 2ch the artist can come out and say "stop that" whereas they might not even speak english.
Just say, "I found this edit, it came from China or Japan," and what not...
This edit is different then the edit in post #21021 .This edit is a cutout of the original image, for people that only what the nice part.post #21021 on the other hand changes the story to abuse.
It still counts since it changes the purpose of the pic through edition, yeah, it was nice looking, but it was part of a sequence meant to show "from good to shit hit the fan" so in a degree it does change it purpose.
Besides, the main problem was of we doing so, since we don't have the feedback of the original artists about them allowing or not like the japanese or chinese artists have, translation is another story, out of necessity we'll need to edit some pics for those that doesn't understand japanese can read the comics without scrolling all the way to the comment that mentions the translation.