I dunno. I don't feel like this is all abyuse.
I mean, he's just teasing her with a little paddling now and then.
If this was really abyuse, there'd be more-permanent damage.
This is more of teasing/playing/bullying.
I don't like abyuse, but I find this cute and slightly charming in it's own unique way.
Seems more like the owner is amusing himself and there really isn't all that much ill will.
also remember that when Yus take a dump they pass the bad as well as the poop